Auction Day Mistakes to Avoid in NSW

Why Auction Day Requires Preparation

In NSW, auctions move quickly. There are no cooling-off periods, no second chances, and no ability to renegotiate once the contract is finalised.

That's why auction day is one of the most significant pressure points for buyers — especially in competitive markets like Wollongong, Shellharbour and Kiama.

The most common mistakes aren't made at the auction itself… They're made before buyers step onto the bidding floor.

Understanding the process, the risks, and the emotional traps is the key to making clear, confident decisions on the day.

Here are the biggest auction day mistakes buyers make — and how to avoid them.

TL;DR — Auction Day Mistakes to Avoid in NSW

• Auctions in NSW are legally binding with no cooling-off period, so mistakes made before the auction are often the most costly.

• Biggest traps include: attending without full finance approval, skipping building/pest inspections, not reviewing the contract, and letting emotions drive bidding.

• On the day, buyers commonly bid too early, use predictable round numbers, reveal too much to agents, or misread crowd dynamics.

• Understanding the auction environment — including price guides, bidder behaviour, and post-auction negotiations — can give you a major strategic edge.

• A buyer's agent can help remove emotion, analyse value, and bid calmly and confidently on your behalf.

• The Shoreline Agency provides auction strategy, bidding services, and pre-auction due diligence for buyers across Wollongong, Shellharbour and Kiama.

1. Arriving Without Proper Due Diligence

The most expensive mistake buyers make is failing to prepare properly before auction day.

Once the hammer falls, you are legally committed to the purchase, with no cooling-off period in NSW auctions.

Mistake 1: Not having the finances fully assessed

Many buyers rely on generic pre-approvals that do not accurately reflect their actual borrowing capacity.

If the bank later values the property lower than the winning bid, the buyer must cover the shortfall in cash — a situation that catches many first-home buyers by surprise.

How to avoid it:

• Ensure your pre-approval is current, verified, and tailored to your specific needs.

• Discuss price buffers with your broker.

• Understand your lender's valuation approach.

Mistake 2: Skipping the building and pest inspection

Some buyers assume the property is "move-in ready" because it presents well online or at open homes.

This can be a costly assumption.

Inspections can reveal:

• Structural issues

• Rising damp

• Pest activity

• Drainage problems

• Unapproved works

How to avoid it: Get the inspection done before auction day — even if it feels like a cost risk.

A $500 report can save you $50,000 in repairs.

Mistake 3: Not reviewing the contract properly

Buyers often skim over key contract conditions:

• Settlement period

• Inclusions and exclusions

• Title restrictions

• Renovation limitations

• Easements or encumbrances

How to avoid it: Have a solicitor or conveyancer review the contract in advance and request amendments if needed (e.g., extended settlement, changes to inclusions).

2. Letting Emotions Influence Bidding Strategy

Auctions are intentionally designed to evoke strong emotions.

Crowds, fast bidding, and competition trigger reactive decisions — especially when buyers have fallen in love with a property.

Mistake 4: Chasing the property emotionally

When buyers decide "this is the one," rational limits disappear.

They justify stretching their budget by assuming future income or by ignoring long-term consequences.

How to avoid it: Set two numbers before the auction:

• Your "walk-away" number

• Your "stretch but safe" number

Write them down. Stick to them.

Mistake 5: Joining the bidding too early

Some buyers open the bidding to "show confidence," but this can build momentum and play into the auctioneer's strategy.

How to avoid it: Observe the pace first. Enter strategically — often once competition thins out or when the property is nearing reserve.

Mistake 6: Using round numbers

Many bidders jump in with neat increments — 900,000K, 920,000K, 950,000K — making their strategy predictable.

How to avoid it: Bid with irregular numbers.

• Try $917,500 instead of $920K.

• Try $951,250 instead of $950K.

Small increments can slow competing bidders and disrupt their rhythm.

Mistake 7: Showing your hand too early

Some buyers tell the agent their maximum budget “to speed things up" or help the agent "guide them."

This information is often used against you.

How to avoid it: Never reveal your actual limit to the selling agent. Only your buyer's agent, who works for you, should know this number.

3. Misreading the Auction Environment

Understanding the dynamics on auction day is a skill. The best buyers (and buyer's agents) read body language, competition strength, auctioneer tactics, and Market tone.

Mistake 8: Assuming the price guide is accurate

Auction price guides often reflect the agent's marketing strategy, rather than the likely sale price. Underquoting rules have improved, but guides still tend to skew conservative to attract competition.

How to avoid it: Review:

• Comparable sales

• Market movement

• Land size

• Renovation level

• Street desirability

This will give you a true value range — not a marketing range.

Mistake 9: Misreading the crowd

Not everyone registering is a serious bidder. Some are observers.

Others have lower budgets. Some bidders may be fatigued from previous failed auctions.

How to avoid it: Pay attention to:

• Body language

• Who asks contract questions

• Who places early bids

• Who hesitates

• Who has their partner present

These small cues help you know when to push and when to pause.

Mistake 10: Not planning for the post-auction negotiation

If the property passes in, the highest bidder usually gets the first right to negotiate. Many buyers assume this process is relaxed — but negotiations immediately after an auction can be intense.

How to avoid it: Have your negotiation plan ready:

• Your maximum limit

• Your preferred terms

• Non-negotiables

• Walk-away point

A calm negotiator often secures the property below expectations.

Check out our Auction Services

Bonus Insight: Why Many Buyers Choose a Buyer's Agent for Auctions

Buying at auction is high-pressure. A buyer's agent:

• Removes emotion from the process

• Bids calmly and strategically

• Protects you from overpaying

• Navigates agent tactics

• Reads the crowd and environment

• Negotiates immediately if the property passes in

In competitive Illawarra suburbs like Thirroul, Bulli, Woonona, Figtree, and Shell Cove, auctions can escalate quickly — making professional representation a valuable advantage.

Auction Day Checklist (Save This)

✔ Finance fully assessed

✔ Contract reviewed

✔ Building/pest inspection completed

✔ Maximum bid set

✔ Walk-away number set

✔ Bidding strategy planned

✔ Registration paperwork completed

✔ Emotional anchors removed

✔ Backup plan ready

✔ Support person or buyer’s agent in place

Need Support Before Auction Day?

If you're planning to bid — whether in Wollongong, Shellharbour, Kiama, or anywhere in NSW — proper preparation will protect you from typical mistakes and help you buy with confidence.

At The Shoreline Agency, we help buyers:

• Prepare properly before auction day

• Analyse comparable sales

• Understand TruMarket value

• Bid strategically and calmly

• Avoid overpaying under pressure

📞 Contact The Shoreline Agency today for auction support or a pre-auction strategy session.

👉 Get in touch →

See you on the Shoreline.